Earlier today, Sen. John Ensign (R-NV) claimed that the U.S. health care system is just fine -- if you don't count injuries from gunshots and car accidents.
"Are you aware that if you take out gun accidents and auto accidents, that the United States actually is better than those other countries?" Ensign said during Senate Finance Committee debate over the public option. ("Those other countries" included France, Germany, Japan and Canada.)
Where did he come up with such an argument? TPMDC's Brian Beutler tracks down the source: Betsy McCaughey said as much when she appeared on the Daily Show last month. McCaughey is the former lieutenant governor of New York and the first person to push the idea that, under health care reform, the government would decide who gets care, who lives and who dies -- a precursor to the "death panel" articulated by Sarah Palin.
On the show, McCaughey said that, without violence and auto accidents, the U.S. would have the highest life expectancy in the world. It was an attempt to undermine an argument for reform, that the U.S. spends more money than any other country but still lags in life expectancy.
The Wall Street Journal explains that McCaughey the idea from a 2006 report published by conservative think tank American Enterprise Institute.

TPM Stories Now Surging on Digg.com

The Confidence Man
September 29, 2009 3:24 PM
Are you aware that if you take out the affair he had, that John Ensign actually is better than those other husbands?
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Savannah Evans
September 29, 2009 3:28 PM in reply to The Confidence Man
Good point. Truth be told, John Ensign has never had extramarital relations, if you don't include all the times he had extramarital relations.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Chris
September 29, 2009 3:45 PM in reply to Savannah Evans
Actually this begs the question, what to do about all those who are in auto and gun accidents that don't have insurance coverage? Should we count them or not?
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
rafaelthatmf
September 29, 2009 6:31 PM in reply to Chris
And Lincoln had only one complaint about that play!
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Linda in Maryland
September 29, 2009 3:32 PM
Well, what do we expect from a man who thinks with a part of the anatomy that is not the brain. Almost sounds like he is making a case for gun control...oh, my!
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
ohyeathatsright
September 29, 2009 3:41 PM
And those injured by guns and cars don't deserve health-care.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Chris
September 29, 2009 3:44 PM
This is excellent news. I bet if we didn't include people who were sick into that we would be entirely unmatched in all realms of human society.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Reece
September 29, 2009 3:47 PM
Does this mean that John Ensign favors gun control?
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
jeffs
September 29, 2009 4:02 PM
Unfair argument. If you remove *all* people in need of medical care, "those other countries" are just as good as the United States.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Ricky
September 29, 2009 4:29 PM
i love it how republicans can cheat on their wife, they stay in their position as if nothing wrong with it.. the HYPOCRISY OF THE GOP IS RIDICULOUS
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
commie atheist
September 29, 2009 5:04 PM
Don't forget that McCaughey's original hit piece on the Clinton health care reform plan in the 90's was funded by Big Tobacco, among others:
"What has not been reported until now is that McCaughey's writing was influenced by Philip Morris, the world's largest tobacco company, as part of a secret campaign to scuttle Clinton's health care reform. (The measure would have been funded by a huge increase in tobacco taxes.) In an internal company memo from March 1994, the tobacco giant detailed its strategy to derail Hillarycare through an alliance with conservative think tanks, front groups and media outlets. Integral to the company's strategy, the memo observed, was an effort to "work on the development of favorable pieces" with "friendly contacts in the media." The memo, prepared by a Philip Morris executive, mentions only one author by name:
' "Worked off-the-record with Manhattan and writer Betsy McCaughey as part of the input to the three-part exposé in The New Republic on what the Clinton plan means to you. The first part detailed specifics of the plan." '
http://jamesfallows.theatlantic.com/archives/2009/09/ok_info_about_b_mccaughey_that.php
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Metzengerstein
September 29, 2009 5:44 PM in reply to commie atheist
And never, never, never forget that the self-loathing-gay-neocon twit Andrew Sullivan made the call to publish her crap in the once-fine TNR, probably slingshotting her into being the LG of New York and giving her a permanent national prominence.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
commie atheist
September 30, 2009 5:26 PM in reply to Metzengerstein
Sullivan has much to atone for. No matter how much he attempts to apologize for his Iraq war cheerleading and his unqualified support for the Bushies, I will never trust him to be truthful about anything.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
go2goal
September 29, 2009 5:37 PM
If we didn't provide health care to wife cheaters, our health care costs would go down and our system wouldn't be rated at #37 in the World. Just think of all the penicillin we'd save if the John Ensign's lost their health care.
"The John Ensign VD Health Care Cost Reduction Act"
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Metzengerstein
September 29, 2009 5:47 PM
And if you don't count all the weapons and materiel procurement or the personnel costs, our defense budget is one of the lowest in the world.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Matt Jones
September 29, 2009 6:37 PM
To truly follow the GOP playbook, we now need an ad with the headline, "Sen. Ensign wants to ban cars and guns". It's as connected to reality as the typical "death panel" nonsense.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?